Cal Poly’s Committee to hunt witches and the politically challenged

witch hunts at Cal Poly: "learn by doing!"
witch hunts at Cal Poly: "learn by doing!"

From what I am told, David Conn is a reasonable and personable fellow, just the person to give what some are calling  Cal Poly’s “Committee of Inquisition” a happy face. I even had people tell me NOT to find any pictures of David Conn in a clown suit on the internet, because he was a such ‘nice guy.’ However, it has been my observation that much of the problems, dare I say ‘evil’, in the world has been supported, initiated and perpetuated by so-called ‘good people’ who believe they were just doing their job and ‘following orders.’ Psychologist Stanley Milgram might agree.

For some reason, Cal Poly’s administration believes there are not enough organizations and systems to handle the various complaints on campus and decreed that a new select committee would be set up and apparently given broad powers and a curious mandate. In addition, the committee would exist without the customary review by the faculty and staff unions or the faculty academic senate… in essence, it would be accountable to no one. Apparently, it would be ‘outside the law.’ It doesn’t take a genius to realize how easily this committee could be used — backed by ‘anonymous’ or non existent accusations — to punish with impunity.

In an attempt to reassure and assuage his colleagues, the affable David Conn was quoted in the recent past Academic Senate Executive meeting  as saying,”

“If accusations are made, the way we handled it is more important. It is not the intention for this to become a witch-hunt unless there is an appropriate base.”

The term  ‘witch hunt’ is disturbingly powerful as is the phrase  “unless there is an appropriate base.”

One of the student member of the committee jokingly referred to as the ‘Inquisitorial Squad” clearly called for action against faculty not viewed as ‘politically correct:”

“All students have had that teacher who isn’t politically correct or is hurtful in their actions or words,” recreation administration junior and future campus advocate Jessica Cresci said.

With Cal Poly’s history in federal court and in fairness to students and faculty, I would urge Cal Poly’s Administration from continuing on this path as it will no doubt lead to unnecessary grief to those guilty of nothing more than a difference in opinion.

Cal Poly needs not be on the wrong side of history once again.

Roger Freberg

Other articles/posts of interest:

Fire’s analysis of Cal Poly’s Care-net

Cal Poly looks to the Board of Inquisition

Article in National Association of Scholars

Cal Poly let’s the clowns out!



Cal Poly taking another look at their ‘Board of Inquisition’

!00firedoesitagain2
Is the Clown down & out?

Maybe not every minor problem Cal Poly San Luis Obispo has with students, faculty or staff has to end up in Federal Court. I would like to hope that folks can learn from their mistakes, take advice from those who wish to make Cal Poly a better place and , hopefully, avoid stepping into it the next time.

Recently, I blogged about what many have called  “Cal Poly’s Inquisition Board” to ferret out Professors and students who were deemed not “politically correct.”  With the sweet sounding name of ‘Care-net’, Cal Poly was at the threshold of setting up a system whereby students and faculty would be held accountable to anonymous accusations and standards not based on law, but pernicious whim. IMHO, this would be a virtual system outside of union contracts, Cal Poly code of conduct standards and common sense… as well as the law.

F.I.R.E. ( the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education)  recognized immediately the arena into which Cal Poly was entering and wrote a stern and forceful letter in defense of faculty and students at Cal Poly. The result: Cal Poly is reevaluating the Care-net program.

Here is F.I.R.E.’s latest statement!

I was able to find  two cached pages of the ill fated Care-Net that are worth reading.

The only question that remains for those of us with decades of experience in dealing with Cal Poly: Will Cal Poly walk away from initiating a “Board of Inquisition”… or will they work harder to not be discovered?

In any event,there are a lot of folks watching to see the next steps Cal Poly administration takes … thanks to F.I.R.E.

Roger Freberg

UPDATE: F.I.R.E. article on this blog

Cal Poly lets the dogs (clowns) out! woof! woof! woof!

The Cal Poly university administrators have had their hands whacked a few times by the likes of  F.I.R.E. ( foundation for individual rights in education) and they don’t like it. They have been warned and they know they can’t directly do ‘business as usual.’  In fact, Cal Poly has been given F.I.R.E.’s worst rating: red.  They seem to be getting smarter, they have found a new way to insulate themselves from criticism and apparently ‘work behind the scenes.’

As a refresher, Cal Poly likes to run — in my humble opinion — fast and loose with the letter of the law. They seem to believe that they can whack you right up until the point you take them to federal court … and they have to roll over. In the meantime, they wasted lots of taxpayer money, time and become a national embarrassment. So famous is their aging  President Warren Baker that he was awarded the ignominious U.S. News and World Report ‘Sheldon” award in 2003! This has been a long standing problem.

The saga continues with the establishment of CARE-net, a nice sounding name for allowing anonymous allegations concerning fellow students and faculty. Setting up a virtual ‘court system’ for the university to put students and faculty (expressing their constitutionally protected free speech)through an unconscionable ordeal just sounds wrong! This reminds me of the unofficial Cal Poly motto “we reward compliance and not achievement.” Unfortunately it shows.  READ:

Snitch Studies at Cal Poly: We Snare Because We Care

Just when you thought things were getting better.

Roger Freberg

UPDATE!!!!!!

Fire’s Letter to Cal Poly’s Warren Baker!

…..the end? or the beginning?

all oars pulling together

Karla's Snake for Biological Psychology
Karla's Snake for Biological Psychology

For those of you who don’t know, Laura has a second edition of her textbook  Discovering Biological Psychology hitting the book shelves and everyone in the family is excited to see her efforts come to fruition.

One of the nice things that happens in our family is that everyone has helped Laura in ways large and small in getting her textbook to press. Whether it has been proof reading, researching, filing…  everyone has tried to help…. all oars pulling together to get the job done. Our daughter Karla came up with an illustration ( as requested by one of Laura’s adopters) that will bring a smile to even the most hardened neuroscientist. The visual shows how orientation changes. Thanks, Karla you made it fun!

Thanks Laura from all of us and Congratulations!

Roger

CNN, Lou Dobbs and Cal Poly

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9Thgt7dEVw[/youtube]

Well, I don’t know how many times Lou Dobbs ‘called out’ the aging President of Cal Poly San Luis Obispo … but it wasn’t pretty.

I’d like to say that Cal Poly doesn’t deserve it, but you can’t help to wonder how many times Cal Poly has to screw up before they finally put the old guy out to pasture and find some reality based thinkers to run the organization rather than a group of ideologues.

I don’t know about you, but in these tough times, most of us want to see our public institutions perform. BTW,  if I were a student, I’d be asking Cal Poly,” Is there a prize for playing this game?”

Roger Freberg

Look for this blog on Yahoo!